England's experts debate their starting XI for the World Cup semi-final against Argentina after a 2-1 victory over Norway.
BBC Experts Select Their England World Cup Semi-Final XI
According to Sports.
Background
The discussion surrounding England's lineup reflects the strategic considerations necessary for success in the World Cup 2026. With injuries affecting key players, the selection of individuals like Ezri Konsa and Morgan Rogers could be critical. Their performances in this semi-final will not only influence the match outcome but also shape the team's overall season outlook as they aim for glory in the tournament.
Why this matters
England's recent victory over Norway has propelled them into the semi-finals of the World Cup 2026, where they will face a formidable Argentina side. The match against Norway highlighted key players like Harry Kane and Jude Bellingham, but also raised questions about the contributions from others, such as Morgan Rogers and Bukayo Saka. As the tournament progresses, the performance of these players will significantly impact England's chances of advancing further.
Key Takeaways
- BBC Experts Select Their England World Cup Semi-Final XI.
- England's experts debate their starting XI for the World Cup semi-final against Argentina after a 2-1 victory over Norway.
- Declan Rice remains central to England's plans.
England has reached the semi-finals of the World Cup and will face Argentina in a highly anticipated match. After a hard-fought 2-1 victory over Norway, the Three Lions are now gearing up for the challenge ahead, with kick-off scheduled for Wednesday at 20:00 BST, broadcast live on the BBC. In light of this significant clash, BBC Sport experts have shared their thoughts on the ideal starting XI for England.
John Murray, senior commentator for BBC Radio 5 Live, believes that experience will be crucial in this encounter. He suggests that John Stones should be included in the starting lineup, especially if Reece James is not fit to start, making Ezri Konsa a likely candidate for right-back. Murray also proposes that Morgan Rogers, who has been effective for Aston Villa, could be a key player on the right flank, especially considering that Noni Madueke and Bukayo Saka have not been performing at their best. He emphasizes that England needs contributions from players other than Harry Kane and Jude Bellingham in terms of scoring, with Rogers potentially stepping up to the challenge.
Phil McNulty, BBC Sport’s chief football writer, notes the difficulty of making selections, particularly given the injuries within the squad. He stresses the importance of Stones' experience during knockout stages and suggests pairing him with Marc Guehi. McNulty would also opt for Konsa at right-back, given James's limited playing time due to injury. Declan Rice's fitness is another concern, but if he is able to play, his presence would be vital. He believes Saka should start over Madueke, citing the need for a win and recognizing that Gordon has shown promise on the left.

Alex Howell, an England reporter for BBC Sport, prefers to keep the back four unchanged from the match against Norway, citing Konsa's stability. Howell is optimistic about Saka's decision-making skills and would retain Kane and Bellingham in the forward line, along with Gordon, who is becoming increasingly influential.
Neil Johnston, another BBC Sport reporter, highlights Stones' adaptability to challenging conditions and believes he should remain in the starting XI. However, he points out that Rice has not been at his best and suggests that Eberechi Eze could be the player to bring energy and pace to the team. Johnston also advocates for James to start if he is fit, while expressing excitement about Rogers potentially making an impact against Argentina.
As England prepares for this critical semi-final, fans are left to ponder the best choices for the starting lineup and how these selections may influence their chances against a formidable opponent in Argentina. The anticipation builds as the match approaches, and supporters eagerly await to see which players will take the field in a bid to secure a place in the World Cup final.
What happens next
Looking ahead to the semi-final, England will need to finalize their starting XI, with experts suggesting crucial roles for experienced players like John Stones and Declan Rice. The match against Argentina is expected to be a tactical battle, and the decisions made by coach Thomas Tuchel will be pivotal. Fans and analysts alike will be watching closely to see how England adapts to the challenges posed by their opponents in this high-stakes World Cup 2026 encounter.
Frequently Asked Questions
What was the score of the England vs Norway match?
England won the match against Norway with a score of 2-1.
How does England's victory over Norway impact their standings?
England's victory over Norway has allowed them to reach the semi-finals of the World Cup.
Who will England face in the next fixture?
England will face Argentina in the semi-finals of the World Cup.
When is the England vs Argentina match scheduled?
The England vs Argentina match is scheduled for Wednesday at 20:00 BST.
What players are suggested for England's starting XI against Argentina?
Experts suggest including players like John Stones, Ezri Konsa, Morgan Rogers, and Bukayo Saka in England's starting XI against Argentina.
Related Articles